From Tradition to Religion

Semana Santa, Sevilla, Spain. source: Shutterstock

Throughout history, human societies have relied on traditions to structure their existence, providing a sense of identity, continuity, and belonging. Traditions arise from practical necessities, cultural expressions, or social customs, but over time, they often transform into sacred beliefs. What begins as a simple, everyday practice may evolve into an unquestionable religious tenet, shaping societal values and restricting creative freedom. This transformation—from tradition to religion—creates a self-perpetuating cycle that can be particularly oppressive to artists, who thrive on breaking boundaries and challenging norms.

The Evolution from the Profane to the Sacred
Many religious beliefs originate from habits and traditions that were initially secular in nature. One clear example is dietary restrictions in various faiths. Kosher and halal laws, for instance, stem from ancient hygienic and environmental concerns—meat spoils quickly in warm climates, and certain animals carried higher risks of disease. Over time, these pragmatic customs solidified into religious commandments, upheld not for their original utility but as divine decrees.

Another example is the tradition of head coverings. In many cultures, covering one's head was initially a mark of modesty or social status. Over time, it became embedded in religious doctrine, such as in Christianity (nuns' habits), Islam (hijabs and turbans), and Judaism (kippahs). What was once a cultural signifier became a religious imperative, enforced with strict moral consequences.

Similarly, ancestor worship in many Asian and African societies began as a means of honoring lineage and preserving family unity. Over generations, it evolved into structured rituals and even deification of ancestors, becoming an essential component of religious observance. The original intention—to respect one's forebears—became a rigid framework dictating how families must engage with their past.

How Traditions Ensnare Society in a Vicious Cycle
The transformation of tradition into religion often leads to stagnation, as customs become immutable laws rather than evolving with societal needs. This rigidity creates a cycle where questioning or deviating from tradition is seen as blasphemous, even when the original context has long disappeared.

For example, arranged marriages were once a practical solution for maintaining family alliances and economic stability. Over centuries, they became deeply entrenched in religious customs, with some societies equating marriage arrangements with divine will. Even in modern contexts where individuals seek autonomy in choosing partners, the weight of tradition remains overwhelming, discouraging change and progress.

The caste system in India provides another stark example. Initially a means of occupational categorization, it evolved into an immutable religious and social hierarchy that restricted personal freedom, mobility, and expression. Despite social reform efforts, the religious framing of caste makes it difficult to dismantle completely, perpetuating inequality.

The Artistic Struggle: Breaking Free from Tradition
​For artists, traditions can be both a source of inspiration and an insidious trap. While many artists draw from cultural heritage, they often find themselves at odds with society when they challenge sacred norms. Throughout history, artists who have dared to reinterpret religious or traditional symbols have faced censorship, persecution, or exile. Consider the case of Caravaggio, whose dramatic, hyper-realistic religious paintings challenged the idealized forms preferred by the Church. His use of common people as models for biblical figures was seen as profane, despite its artistic brilliance. Similarly, modern artists like Ai Weiwei in China have faced political and religious backlash for their critical engagement with tradition.

Women artists, in particular, struggle against traditions that confine them to rigid roles. In societies where traditional gender norms are reinforced by religious doctrine, female artists who depict themes of sexuality, power, or autonomy often face intense scrutiny. The mere act of creating art can be seen as rebellion, as witnessed in the censorship of women’s literature, paintings, and performances throughout history.

Breaking the Cycle
If traditions become rigid religious beliefs, how can society—and particularly artists—break free? The answer lies in constant questioning and reinterpretation. Traditions should be living entities, open to adaptation rather than static dictates. Just as folklore evolves with each retelling, so too should our relationship with inherited customs.

Artists play a crucial role in this process. By reimagining traditions, they highlight their contradictions, expose their outdated elements, and offer alternative perspectives. This requires courage, as breaking sacred customs often invites backlash. Yet, history has shown that artistic rebellion can lead to cultural transformation.

One example is the Harlem Renaissance, where African American artists reclaimed and redefined their cultural and religious heritage through literature, music, and visual arts. By taking ownership of their narrative, they challenged stereotypes rooted in both social tradition and religious dogma. Similarly, feminist artists in the 20th and 21st centuries have used their work to critique patriarchal traditions that have been enshrined in religious doctrine.
 
The evolution from tradition to religion is a powerful force that shapes society, often in ways that limit progress and creative expression. What begins as simple, secular practice can become a binding rule, enforced with the weight of divine authority. While traditions provide cultural continuity, they also risk trapping individuals, especially artists, within a cycle of dogma and suppression.

The challenge lies in maintaining a balance: respecting cultural heritage while allowing room for growth, interpretation, and change. Artists, philosophers, and free thinkers must continue to push boundaries, questioning the validity of inherited customs. Only by doing so can society escape the vicious cycle of tradition and embrace a more dynamic, evolving cultural landscape.

---